Meet the Staff

Get to know the people behind your banking experience. Our team is local, experienced, and here to help.

Learn More
Contact Us
Panoramic view of a rural farmland with green fields, multiple white farmhouses, silos, and a blue sky with scattered clouds.

Our Team

Our team is here to serve with experience, care, and a commitment to your goals. We’re proud to be your neighbors and your trusted banking partners. Connect with the right person to help you take the next step.

Learn More
Contact Us
Branch Managers
Loan Officers
Operations
Executives
Angie Fullenkamp
Branch Manager
Botkins

NMLS# 1828265
Phone: 937-693-1537
Email: afullenkamp@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with short brown hair and glasses wearing a blue top against a neutral blurred background.
Patricia Yinger
Branch Manager
Sidney

NMLS# 1600237
Phone: 937-492-1292
Email: pyinger@firstnbank.bank

Smiling middle-aged woman with short blonde hair, wearing glasses and a dark top, against a neutral background.
Jessica Schulze
Branch Manager
Wapakoneta

NMLS# 628119
Phone: 419-738-2194
Email: jschulze@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with long straight blonde hair wearing a black jacket over a yellow top.
Crissie Mooney
Branch Manager
New Knoxville

Phone: 419-753-3456
Email: cmooney@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with long brown hair wearing a black top and a small necklace against a light background.
Katina L. Shaffer
Consumer Loan Manager
New Bremen

NMLS# 592431
Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: kshaffer@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with curly blonde hair, glasses, and a mauve blouse against a blurred gray background.
Christa McNaughton
Commercial Loan Operations Manager
New Bremen

NMLS# 629420
Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: cmcnaughton@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with short dark hair wearing a patterned top against a blurred background.
Jeff Wolters
Commercial Loan Officer
New Bremen

NMLS# 851777
Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: jwolters@firstnbank.bank

Portrait of a smiling man with short light brown hair wearing a navy suit, white shirt, and maroon tie against a brown blurred background.
Cherie Huston
Business Services Manager
New Bremen

Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: chuston@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with shoulder-length brown hair wearing glasses and a black top with a decorative necklace.
Claire Archey
Business Services Representative
New Bremen

Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: carchey@firstnbank.bank

Smiling woman with shoulder-length brown hair wearing glasses and a black top with a decorative necklace.
Jerry S. Lehman, Jr.
President
New Bremen

NMLS: #509396
Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: jlehman@firstnbank.bank

Middle-aged man in a gray suit, white shirt, and red tie smiling against a neutral background.
Brad Barga
Vice President
Chief Operations Officer
New Bremen

Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: bbarga@firstnbank.bank

Man with brown hair and glasses wearing a dark suit, blue shirt, and striped tie, smiling against a blurred brown background.
Andrew I. Roiberg

Vice President
Chief Financial Officer
New Bremen

Phone: 419-629-2761
Email: aroiberg@firstnbank.bank

Professional headshot of a man with short dark hair wearing a black suit, white shirt, and patterned tie against a neutral background.

Personal Banking

With our Personal Banking services, you’ll find checking and savings accounts designed for your lifestyle, competitive loan options, investment opportunities, and digital tools that make managing money easy.

Learn More
Smiling man wearing a checkered shirt talking on a phone while leaning on the open door of a white car at sunset.
open envelope icon

Message From The President

Hear directly from our President about First National Bank’s commitment to service, technology, and the community we proudly call home.

Learn More

Business Banking

Our Business Banking services offer checking and savings solutions, lending options, cash management tools, and digital support to help your business grow efficiently.

Learn More
Silhouette of a combine harvester working in a field during a colorful sunset.
bank icon

Our History

For generations, First National Bank has been a trusted partner in our community, helping individuals and businesses achieve their financial goals.

Learn More
Relationship Focused. Service Driven.

Think Local. Think Excellence.

First
First
Contact Us